Who's my last keeper?(WHIR)

[Inukchuk]

Konerko or Butler. Floyd was lucky last year.

Totally agree (259 BABIP). Floyd's durability should also be questioned. I don't see him getting close to 200 IP this year.

[kidsilk]

Butler or Konerko?

[claudish21]

I'd go with Butler. He's got the alot of potential that he'll show this year.

[sigriffey]

Hey man,

I really do prefer Floyd, but can respect the need for offense.

Between those, I take Butler just because Konerko has screwed me for several years now... not a big fan. Butler screwed me last year too, but there is at least the youth and upside with him.

[Hit Factory]

I would take Butler as well. Konerko is on the fast track to Bobby Higginson-ville lol. I had Gavin Floyd on my team last year and I like him, but I also really like Butler and think he can materialize into a terrific hitter. That being said, I would take Butler.