Keeper Question

[targasf]

I am in a 10 Team NL only ROTO league with three keepers that can be drafted one round before you got them the year before.

I have 5 that I am looking at and need a little help. Here are my options. Which three would you take?

Furcal 11th
Hamels 5th
Doumit 10th
McClouth 11th
Sherzer 12th
Conor Jackson 8th

Any help would be appreciated.

[rails80]

Furcal, Doumit, McLouth ... only possible switch is Hamels instead of McLouth but with only 3, I'd rather take all hitters and draft pitching.

[targasf]

really and leave hamels out even if he is healthy.

any other thoughts?

[happyturtle]

Furcal is a no-brainer in the 11th.

Hamels is good value there.

and McLouth is great value that late. Doumit is a nice player at a shallow position but not so great to pass up any of those 3 guys.

I like Jackson and Scherzer alot but your other options are far better.

[Seanyfever]

Furcal, Hamels, McLouth

[rails80]

In an NL only league, C becomes even more shallow, no? Figure Martin, Soto & McCann are kept. You have the 4th best-hitting NL catcher on your roster already. I expect a regression in average, but even if he drops 40 pts, he's still hitting .280. If you keep Doumit, you still have picks in the first 8 rounds. If you keep Hamels, you're losing your 4th rounder and need to draft a Catcher. I'd rather keep those 8 picks and draft pitching...

But, I guess you could keep Hamels and draft a guy like Jesus Flores or John Baker...