holliday for hallady? WHIR

[trevizzle]

10 teams 5x5 H2H

C Matt Weiters
1B Carlos Pena
2B Ian Kinsler
3B Aramis Ramirez
SS Jhonny Peralta
LF Matt Holliday
CF Grady Sizemore
RF Vladimir Guerrero
Utl Torii Hunter
Bn Johnny Damon

Sp Rich Harden
Sp Scott Kazmir
Rp B.J. Ryan
Rp Joel Hanrahan
P Matt Capps
P Derek Lowe
P Josh Johnson
Bn Chris Young
Bn Jon Lester
Bn Mark Buerhle
Bn Dontrelle Willis

so a lot of people told me i need help in the pitching department, so i have halladay for holliday on the table...yes or no?

leave a link

[Bea Arthur]

That's a tough one, but I would say 'yes'. Halladay is the most reliable pitcher in the game and right now your two best starters (Kazmir and Harden) are both very injury prone. Plus you don't know how Holliday will be outside of Coors. I would definitely cut Willis though and pick up an extra OF if you do that trade.

Help w/mine

viewtopic.php?t=372137

[crookedmacs]

That's something to think about. You know what you're getting with Halladay. Holliday in the AL, not so much. I would do the deal because I'm high on Halladay. Lots of innings, solid K's. Wish they had a better offense, but I'm just not high on Holliday


here's mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=371950

[trevizzle]

bump

[BALCO All-Stars]

Although you definitely need the SP bump, IMO Holliday > Halladay.

Side note, cut Willis to get a C while Wieters is playing at AAA.

[shoelessjoetara]

Depends what is on the WW. I would keep Holiday and look on the WW for a SP.

[21st bluejayway]

holliday 280 BA outside of coors is somewhat puzzling, but more of a concern when SLG% is cut in half as well. but considering your team is a 10 team league, im pretty sure u could find a decent sp. so if i was u, i would do a small 2 for 1 trade, if you feel it is necessary to make a trade.

[Seanyfever]

I like initial thought, but balance this by adding some second palyers. Straight up, I pass.

Help target my next 3 picks. Coming soon.
viewtopic.php?t=372167