Soria/Ubaldo for Gomez/Sherrill/C. Perez

[chargersfan36]

I'm in a 12-team 5x5 roto league and this trade was offered to me.

My Soria, U. Jimenez for C. Gomez, G. Sherrill, and Chris Perez.

C - B. Molina
C - Napoli
1b - A. Gonzalez
2b - K. Johnson
3b - A. Ramirez
SS - Lowrie
CI - Glaus
MI - C. Guzman
OF - Hamilton
OF - Beltran
OF - Ludwick
OF - Span
OF - JD Drew
Util - Kotchman
BN - M. Cameron
BN - Lowell
P - Haren
P - Billingsley
P - Harden
P - C. Young
P - Jurrjens
P - U. Jimenez
P - Marmol
P - Soria
P - Devine
BN - K. Escobar

Do you think this trade would help me? I want to at least be competitive in steals and not left in the dust and I think the more closers the better. Can I expect Sherrill and Perez to each save 30 games this season? Also, what's the status of Minnesota's OF?

Thanks. WHIR.

[HOOTIE]

Bad deal. Sherrill is crap, Ray likely to close. perez is iffy, as Tony likes Franklins experience, and Motte is there. I think Jimenez is the 2nd best guy in deal.

[joe112]

No. This trade stinks

[dave knight]

You're giving away the two best players, which makes it an automatic no-deal.

[Seanyfever]

You players are both better. Keep them.

Help target my next 3 picks. Coming soon.
viewtopic.php?t=372167

[kylep15]

Not even close. Soria is a top 5 closer and Ubaldo can be huge this year. The other three are scraps. please reply to this question: viewtopic.php?t=372223