Keep Trade

[Johnny Tuttle]

Edit: I did the deal, please weigh in.

It's not a long thread, folks.

[tribefan08]

thanks for the help on mine, some of these really deep leagues are way over my head and i know my shizz.... haha, i know gamel is a stud and if i could attain him (since i do own him on my team just waiting for the call up) i'd stick with him, all the deals are tough for me to call.. .... i know the names just not all the info

[dave knight]

Of course I'd do either one - Porcello and Alvarez are much better prospects than Gamel. I like the Alvarez deal better. Scouts have compared him to a young Pujols.

[Johnny Tuttle]

Update:

Do I do Adam Miller (Cleveland), Figgy, and Gamel

4

Oliver Perez the Met, Uggla, and Porcello?

I could have Randy Johnson, Maholm, or another guy I forget already in place of Perez, but I like Perez's work post pitching coach change.

Thanks.

[kidsilk]

I like the last updated deal for you. Gamel isnt as great of a prospect as Porcello in my opinion and like the addition of Uggla.

thanks for your help with mine

[Johnny Tuttle]

Update: This is more of a how did I do thread now: I took it. The RBI/OPS/HR differences between Figgins and Uggla scared me into saying yes (It's a 6 x 6, holds and OPS in). I have little to no SBs anyways, and I'm not scared of BA in a h2h league.

Is Oliver Perez still hot and cold like he was two years ago? He's my 8th starter (most teams have 6 or 7), and I can afford to be choosey about deploying him.

[killertofu2222]

he's all over the place. i dont like him. i'm also a huge phillies fan so my opinion is extremely biased

[Johnny Tuttle]

I'm just hoping that as an 8th man, he'll be OK.

To be honest, I would have done the deal without him, and so I'll drop him quickly if he doesn't work out.