C.C. or Brandon Webb

[mmullaney]

take webb if you want to relax and have a safe great season...
but take cc if you want to risk a little for a better upside. granted cc has some extra mclovin but if he stays healthy with teh yanks (and as a sox fan it hurts to say) he will have a tremendous season. prediction if healthy 25 wins well north of 250 k's and a cy young award. as for webb...the hohum usual of 19 wins and steady performance.
you decide from there

[jswede]

I know CC's had some minor injuries coming out of spring training a most years, but he's never put in less than 28 starts in a year. In fact, he's only been under 30 that one time, to go with 34 and 35 in each of his last 2 seasons. He had more innings last year, and in 07, than did Webb. What's with the "if CC can stay healthy" qualifiers?

To answer the post, I'll take CC. by a round or two.