Youkilis/Davis/Ibanez for Holliday/Zimmerman/CYoung/Cantu?

[Jakra]

5x5 Roto League. Different variations of it have been offered to me over the past couple of weeks. Don't plan on accepting it but wanted to get a second opinion and also see if anybody had any ideas on a counter, or should I just reject and let it go. The Chris Young being offered is the OF and not the pitcher.

My Team
C - Shoppach
1B - Youkilis
2B - Phillips
3B - C Davis
SS - Rollins
OF - Sizemore, Ibanez, Werth
UT - A Gonzalez
BN - Wieters, Hawpe

SP - Lester, J Johnson, Slowey, Danks, Cueto, Jer Weaver
RP - Broxton, Wood, Ryan, Percival

His Team
C - McCann
1B - Cantu
2B - K Johnson
3B - Zimmerman
SS - Reyes
OF - Soriano, Holliday, Ludwick
UT - Wells
BN - CYoung, Bradley, Konerko

SP - Webb, Liriano, Lee, Young, Carpenter, Morrow
RP - Bell, Sherrill, Devine