Peralta for Nady 10 Team H2H

[Youngsir620]

I was offered Jhonny Peralta for my Xavier Nady

League stats are R, H, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP

My team not including pitching

C Joe Mauer
(Min - C)
1B Albert Pujols
(StL - 1B)
2B Chase Utley
(Phi - 2B)
3B Álex Rodríguez
(NYY - 3B)
SS Troy Tulowitzki
(Col - SS)
OF Manny Ramírez
(LAD - OF)
OF Matt Holliday
(Oak - OF)
OF Torii Hunter
(LAA - OF)
Util Garrett Atkins
(Col - 1B,3B)
BN Xavier Nady
(NYY - OF)
BN Brad Hawpe
(Col - OF)
BN Adam Jones
(Bal - OF)
BN Alexi Casilla
(Min - 2B)
BN Mark Reynolds
(Ari - 3B)
BN Ramón Hernández
(Cin - C)

[HOOTIE]

Yes. Nady is badly overrated.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd do it. I like Peralta over Nady.

[pokerplaya]

You don't seem to need the SS help, but I'd do it anyway. Peralta is more valuable than Nady by a large margin, and if for no other reason than perceived value (you could simply re swap Peralta for a more valuable piece) you definitely should do it.

[jake_twothousandfive]

Yes. Nady is badly overrated.

Agreed that Nady is overrated. Peralta is a great backup for Tulo should he not have the bounce back year we're all expecting.

You're filling a need and getting excellent value in the process. Do it.

[Peeig]

Take Peralta.............even though you have SS filled, you can always turn around and trade one of your SS for an upgrade elsewhere. Just take value where you can get it.

[dave knight]

Yes. Nady is badly overrated.

[trevizzle]

yeah i go for it. you have a very good of, and i love peralta. he's dead on for 20 hrs and 80 rbi's and a .275 avg. who knows what tulo is going to do