7 Guys for 5 Keeper Spots

[Geek]

Reyes, Miggy, Greinke, Dunn, Fuentes. I don't believe in keeping question marks.

Mine:

viewtopic.php?f=29&t=371944

[dave knight]

I've identified 7 guys of which I can only keep 5. I have 3 Locks but here they all are:

1)Jose Reyes
2)Miguel Cabrera
3)Zack Greinke
4) Adam Dunn
5)Matt Garza
6)Brian Fuentes
7)Erik Bedard

So, who should it be? I certainly WHIR.

[dave knight]

I don't even think Fuentes is a lock to hold down a closer role if you look at his history, so not there. I don't get the hate on Garza. Great team, nice ratios. Bedard has really let himself go.

[ayebatter]

1)Jose Reyes
2)Miguel Cabrera
3)Zack Greinke
4) Adam Dunn
5)Matt Garza

These work for me.

[j24jags]

1)Jose Reyes
2)Miguel Cabrera
3)Zack Greinke
4) Adam Dunn
5)Matt Garza

These work for me.

[Pedros Little Friend]

not a big garza fan here. i'd roll the dice with bedard, as risky as it may be.

[BigRed2111]

Depends what you are planning on doing with your draft...
If you are going to draft a hitter, then a pitcher with your first two picks, I'd take Garza (you know where his basement is, don't know where his ceiling is)
If you are going to go pitcher, then hitter, I'd go Bedard (higher ceiling then Garza, could easily be just as hurt)

Help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=372403