Keeper Advice Needed - NL

[Phishwick]

I can only keep three of the following four keepers and am struggling about which one to let go:

Ianetta - $7
Daniel Murphy - $8
Ethier - $16
Fielder - $18

I'm leaning towards leaving Ethier out of the mix figuring that I will keep Ianetta because catching is scarce, Murphy due to being cheap with unknown upside, Fielder being in better shape this year with potential repeat of 2007. But Ethier is really good and should play full time so it is hard. Thoughts?

[NCAARules]

I had the same decision to make (at slightly different prices) on everyone except fielder.

Depending on the depth of your league, I would throw back ethier because of how high his price is.

[HOOTIE]

Murphy. Ethier will easily earn the $8 more he costs.

[dave knight]

I can only keep three of the following four keepers and am struggling about which one to let go:

Ianetta - $7
Daniel Murphy - $8
Ethier - $16
Fielder - $18

Ethier and Fielder are top shelf talent, and Iannetta is a top 5 catchers (apart from the newcomer Wieters).