Please help! Which closer?

[redpucks12]

These guys are still available: Lyon, Sherrill, Perez, Reyes, Wheeler, Balfour, Corpas, Gregg, Motte.

I was going to drop Hermida for one.

12 team yahoo traditional scoring.

my team:

C: Sanduval
1b: Pujols
2b: Utley
3b: Encarnacion
SS: Hardy
OF: Beltran
OF: Pence
OF: Dunn
Util: B. Roberts
Bench: Matsui, Blalock, Hermida

SP: Peavy
SP: Lee
RP: street
RP: hoffman
P: Cain
P: Dempster
P: C. Young
BN: smoltz, J. Johnson

[Amazinz]

I prefer Lyon. Tigers didn't pay him $4M+ not to close and I think he's a lock for 30 SV. Corpas is also interesting but although his current performance doesn't back this up, have the hunch Street eventually claims it. Sherill is probably being drafted higher than both these guys but have zero faith in him.

[dave knight]

Lyon will win ugly, but at least he is clear number 1 for the job. Pick him up.

[MadDog36]

I'd try to do a 2 for 1 trade and upgrade at 3b, then dump Encarnacion for a closer or grab one with the free spot. hermida is having a nice spring and is due to break out this year. Its put up or shut up time for him. I wouldn't outright Hermida just yet. Try to package Dunn and Roberts for a 3b upgrade....then with the free spot add Lyon.

Post ww 3b.
Post ww SP.
Post other teams rosters with more than one good 3b.