I'm not sure how late you can get him, but I definitely like him...even moreso in OPS leagues. He is one of the only Colorado players who hits equally well on the road as at home. I honestly don't know why he is rated with such mediocrity this season. I took him at pick 9.12 (#108) in a 6x6 league with OPS (and starting 5 OF) and was quite happy with the pick. He'll be turning 30 this season, so he's still in his prime...and he's incredibly consistent.
The only knocks on him that I can think of are as follows...he's been carrying around a BABIP which is a too high to sustain (.346 on average the past 3 years), he probably peaked/reached his ceiling in 2007 (29HR, 116RBI, .920OPS), and his surrounding cast isn't as potent as it has been (Holliday's gone and Atkins has regressed). That's not enough to scare me away in round 10 of an OPS league. I see mocks around here where he goes in round 12, but that seems too late for him IMO. I didn't expect him to sustain his 2007 numbers in 2008, so while some may see a guy on the decline, I see a guy who regressed to his mean...a very productive mean (25HR, 85RBI, .879OPS).
IMO He has great value this year relative to his ADP...particularly in OPS leagues.
I consider him a 3rd OF.