Keep - Upton vs. Upton

[redrogue5]

I'm in a standard 5x5 keeper league, auction style. I've got three keeper slots. I'm leaning towards Votto for $6 and Hamels for $19. That leaves one slot for either BJ Upton at $15 or Justin Upton at $6. BJ probably is the better value for 09 and helps in steals but Justin will be a better keeper for next year (I can keep him for 2009 and 2010 for $13).

Which Upton to choose?

[footballisbetter.com]

Since you say Justin will be a better keeper in 2010, does that mean you can't keep BJ next year? BJ is definetly the better keeper for at least 2 years, if not more.

[HOOTIE]

Keep both Uptons for $21 and drop Hamels.

[dave knight]

I'd keep Upton...Keep both of them and throw back Hamels.