Would you do this Weaver for Floyd

[128franco]

American League only 12 team keeper league, both pitchers are the same price, would you trade Jered Weaver for Gavin Floyd, is this a fair deal, at present I have Lackey, Verlander, Slowey, I am the one giving up Weaver and I also have Adenhart, either way I feel I will have to buy another starter, but the quality of that extra starter is up in the air

[dave knight]

No, Weaver is much better for you.

[bazzy_51]

if you are confident that Weaver is 100% back then i would stick with him, but i still think Floyd will give you more wins, better ERA and WHIP, Weaver will give you more Ks... but if Weaver is totally back i may put up closer W totals and a close to Floyd type whip, still think his ERA will be much higher...

help me out...
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=371608

[soty]

I'd rather have Weaver.

[dave knight]

The White Sox will be awful this year, so I wouldn't expect more wins from Gavin. I like Weaver's track record better.

[MaudDib]

I'd rather have Weaver.

[DaShiz23]

I'd rather have Weaver.

+ 2

[espnsportsfan]

i would stick with weaver like others have said

[HOOTIE]

I'd rather have Weaver.