Trading Haren and Manny... WHIR

[mister_jay_peg]

I was sent a lowball offer of Delgado/Mags/Zambrano for Haren/Manny. No way I take that, because Big Z has fallen further each of the last 3 years.

I've got a few options from him for countering, but none of them seem great, either.

First is Ordonez/Huff/Kazmir for Manny/Haren.
Next is Ordonez/Beckett/Delgado for Manny/Haren.
Then Oswalt/Ordonez for Manny/Haren.
Last is Oswalt/Ordonez/Huff for Manny/Haren/Loney.

Not thrilled with any of these offers.

If you want to build a counter offer, here are the teams:

My roster:

C. B. Molina
1b. J. Loney
2b. C. Utley
ss. M. Young
3b. G. Atkins
OF. M. Ramirez
OF. J. Bay
OF. B. Hawpe
UT. B. Abreu
UT. C. Beltran

SP. D. Haren
SP. J. Vazquez
SP. J. Shields
RP. B. Wilson
RP. B. Ryan
RP. C. Perez
P. J. Saunders
P. M. Buehrle
P. G. Meche

BN. C. Figgins
BN. T. Hoffman
BN. I. Stewart
BN. B. Ziegler
BN. G. Balfour
BN. C. Bucholz
BN. JP Howell


His roster:

C. Dioner Navarro
1b. Ryan Howard
2b. Dan Uggla
ss. Derek Jeter
3b. Jorge Cantu
OF. Grady Sizemore
OF. Ichiro Suzuki
OF. Magglio Ordonez
UT. David Ortiz
UT. Carlos Delgado

SP. Roy Oswalt
SP. Scott Kazmir
SP. Josh Beckett
RP. Jose Valverde
RP. Brian Fuentes
RP. Scot Shields
P. Carlos Zambrano
P. Cliff Lee
P. Chien Ming Wang

BN. Aubry Huff
BN. Torii Hunter
BN. Pat Burrell
BN. John Smoltz
BN. Manny Corpas
BN. Hank Blalock
BN. Aaron Cook

[Kimbos Beard]

First is Ordonez/Huff/Kazmir for Manny/Haren.
Next is Ordonez/Beckett/Delgado for Manny/Haren.
Then Oswalt/Ordonez for Manny/Haren.
Last is Oswalt/Ordonez/Huff for Manny/Haren/Loney.

None of those trades are even close to being equal for you.

He does have alot of pitching, and you could use a littler deeper SP but none of the combos I see I really like.

[queencitysluggerr]

yeah i think all of those counter offers are terrible for you. your starting pitching seems to be your weak spot and one of his strong spots so see if you can work something there

Help? thanks
viewtopic.php?t=371575

[JoshDJays]

Not worth doing in my opinion.

[DaveClay12]

Add my name in agreement. Don't bother.

If you get a chance:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=371480

[Elsy]

None of those are good....try getting Beckett for Abreu