HELP NEEDED!!!! ONLY ONE CHOICE <>??

[mmullaney]

OK HERE IS MY QUANDRY!
5x5 mixed standard scoring keeper league. 4th pick in draft and these are the most likely available players:

holliday
beltran
soriano
crawford
bj upton
ichiro
which of these guys should i go with? they all have blend of speed and power. disregarding the keeper factor, who is the best bet for the best year this year? thanks guys i have been struggling with this and i cant seem to make up my mind. i will go with the majority votes. thanks again i appreciate your advice

[lastingsgriller]

i'd go holliday
if he's gone, beltran
if he's gone soriano
if hes gone upton


help...
viewtopic.php?t=371526

[DaveClay12]

I'm more curious than most to see how Oakland will affect Holliday's stats. I think he might drop more than most.

I'd go

Beltran
Holliday
Soriano
Upton (but since it's a keeper league, I'd think about taking Upton over Soriano even)

If you get a chance...
[url]
viewtopic.php?t=371480[/url]

[Elsy]

Beltran
Upton
Soriano
Holliday - hitting in AL, especially Oakland is going to hurt his value
Crawford

That is how I rank them

[MadDog36]

Beltran
Holliday
Upton

for this year

in keeper

upton
holliday
beltran

[mmullaney]

anyone else have an opinion on this???? so far its leaning toward beltran.

[bazzy_51]

i say keeper league hmmm...

Beltran
Upton
Soriano
Holliday - will still have a good average, but HR totals will dip a bit... coors helped him and any hitter a ton...
Crawford

help me out...
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=371608

[HOOTIE]

Holliday or BJ.

I would take BJ, because at worst he goes 20/40, and he's the best keeper of the bunch.

[dave knight]

4 holliday
3 beltran
2 soriano
5 crawford
1 bj upton
6 ichiro

[footballisbetter.com]

I would go with Upton. I think he will have the best year this season and future years. Beltran would be my 2nd choice.