HOOTIE wrote:Last year earned,
I wouldn't lock Fielder in as a keeper yet, Kemp/Halladay are better.
Carlos Lee missed about the last 40 games of the year to a broken pinkie. When he went out he was absolutely beasting it and was going to put up the best offensive numbers of his career.
You can't compare Kemp's worth to Lee's last year because Kemp played in 40 more games and got 170 more AB's.
That being said I can see why you may want to take Kemp, but I think its a question of steals over power. Over the next 3 years I think Carlos Lee will put up better power numbers than Kemp, but Kemp is obviously going to give you those SB's.