Someone dropped Carpenter...but who do I drop?

[djxskillz]

I really want Chris Carpenter and he was just dropped for some reason (no idea why...hes having a great spring so far). Anyways, I know for sure someone in my league is going to use their waiver on him but I have the #1 Waiver. I believe Carpenter is someone that is risky but could potentially provide huge dividends. So now the problem. Who do I drop? Right now since I have 5 closers, I think I should drop either Corpas or Percival. What do you guys think?

Yahoo 12 teams 5x5 H2H KEEPER league
C-Matt Wieters
1B-Mark Teixeira
2B-Chone Figgins
3B-Ryan Zimmerman
SS-Rafael Furcal
OF-Nate Mclouth
OF-Jayson Werth
OF-Vernon Wells
UTIL-Hideki Matsui
BN-Carlos Guillen
BN-Mark Reynolds

SP-Johan Santana
SP-CC Sabathia
SP-Erik Bedard
RP-Bobby Jenks
RP-Bj Ryan
P-Mike Gonzalez
P-Troy Percival
BN-Manny Corpas
BN-Jair Jurrgens
BN-Wandy Rodriguez

[sigriffey]

My vote is Mike Gonzalez or Wandy Rodriguez ... but make sure you feel confident in Carpenter before doing so. If so, those would be the guys IMO.

Help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=371227

[APAP]

Bye Mike Gonzalez.

[djxskillz]

why mike gonzalez? i feel like he is clearly better than percival and corpas...

[Johnny Tuttle]

Wandy. He's 30, and in a keeper, he's not a big loss. He's always on the cusp of being dropped anyways.

Keep the closers--they're worth too much to just drop.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=371093

[HOOTIE]

Why would you cut Gonzalez, he's closing? He's a better pitcher then Corpas or Percival.

Don't cut Wandy. He has a 8.6 DOM rate.

Corpas isn't closing. Cut Corpas.

[djxskillz]

yea i really like wandy this year.

[djxskillz]

i actually am starting to think corpas is more valuable than percival. looks like im leaning towards cutting percival.