Shields for Bruce in a Keeper

[Ols]

I trade
James Shields

I get
Jay Bruce

Does my pitching depth justify this trade?

10 team H2H Keeper
Scoring: H,R,HR,RBI,SB,AVG/ W,K,SV,ERA,WHIP,CG,SHO

My team

C Shoppach
1b MCab
2b Alexei
3b Davis
SS Drew
IF Chipper
LF Braun
CF Kemp
RF Justin Upton
OF Maybin
Util Dunn
Bench Loney,Crisp,Felipe Lopez,John Baker

SP Shields
SP Billingsley
P Joba
P Volquez
P Greinke
RP Cordero
RP Valverde
Bench Baker,Slowey,Josh Johnson,Lyon

[Cards10WS]

I like this trade for you, especially in a long term keeper. Your pitching is fine and you could definitely upgrade Bruce over Maybin at OF. Pull the trigger.

Please help
/viewtopic.php?t=371212

[mak1277]

Yep, I like this one. In a 10-team league, you need as many stars and potential stars as possible. Shields is a nice pitcher, but Bruce is a potential star.

[Johnny Tuttle]

Yes, yes, a dozen times yes.