Beltran vs Rollins -- WHIR

[cornandacobb]

8x7 roto league
11 keepers
$1,000 salary cap


I have Beltran at $130
I can acquire Rollins for $110

Not much of a difference in salary.
Just looking for feedback regarding talent and talent at position.

Who is more valuable today?
Will Rollins bounce back to 06/07 form?
Will the more friendly confines of the new stadium help Beltran's numbers?


As of now I am not protecting any MIs.
Thanks.

[Cards10WS]

I like Rollins more this year. .285 125 25 85 and 40 seems about right for Rollins, whereas I have Beltran at .275 105 25 105 and 20.
As you can see, Beltran's only real advantage is RBI.

Please help
/viewtopic.php?t=371212

[Johnny Tuttle]

With positional scarcity, this is a lock. And the slight savings is gravy.

[S27]

I'd be all over Rollins. (Position played & much greater upside in steals. Everything else statistically is likely pretty close except for RBIs where Beltran has the advantage.)

viewtopic.php?t=371257

[TheBull]

Rollins, for the simple fact of position scarcity

[Dodgerbluesc]

Are you saying you can trade Rollins for Beltran? That is an easy choice - Rollins all the way. Reasons listed above.

[METS 24]

Deleted

[mwlsld]

This year in particular, there are a lot of good center fielders out there. Losing Beltran won't kill you...go with position scarcity all the way.

[kidsilk]

Go with Rollins for sure.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=371262

[Kuji]

Only reason i'd jump on Rollins is the production he gives me at such a thin position, where as Beltran is very VERY under appreciated in fantasy baseball.

I think Rollins is more injury prone, but if I needed someone good in SS, go for Rollins. You'll get more guys similar (emphasis on similar) to Beltran later.