Who Wins This BIG Trade?

[TheGhost]

Who wins this trade?

Adrian Gonzalez
Evan Longoria
Scott Kazmir
Jermaine Dye

for

Prince Fielder
Nelson Cruz
Russell Martin
Roy Oswalt

[wheels]

Without knowing the rest of the rosters, I'd rather have Gonzo, Longoria, Dye and Kaz...for sure!

please help...viewtopic.php?t=371129

[HOOTIE]

A

It's close, and a lot depends on Cruz. But i think A has the best player, and B the worst.

[Fantasy Star]

The first group wins big IMO.

[Kuji]

I'd actually go for B, but like it's been already said, we don't know how Nelson Cruz will play this year (i feel he'll be good, just not amazingly awesome).

I'd go with A, but I wouldn't regret going to B either.

[Kimbos Beard]

I would go with A too, but its more of an edging out than a "Win" on the trade. Both sides have good value.