My team is stacked, but I have some extra weight and some holes to fill. I regrettably listened to some of you on this board and kept Carlos Quentin as my 10th keeper over Francisco Liriano. I know it was the right decision, but now I have Quentin sitting on the bench and could use Liriano on my staff. Not to mention the fact that the height of my man crush for Liriano reaches the tops of Mt. Everest. So anyway, Liriano went #1 overall in our draft, and the guy that drafted him wants Longoria. I have David Wright as my starting 3B and Longoria as a UTIL or bench player. I think I could pull of something like Longoria and Josh Johnson for Kinsler and Liriano. He really wants Longoria, I really want Liriano, and Kinsler would be a huge upgrade over Polanco at 2B. Help me out and I will certainly return the favor. Roster is below...
C: Jorge Posada 1B: Albert Pujols 2B: Placido Polanco 3B: David Wright SS: Christian Guzman LF: Matt Holliday CF: Carlos Beltran RF: Vlad Guerrero UTIL: Alfonso Soriano BN: Evan Longoria BN: Carlos Quentin BN: Carlos Guillen BN: Adam Lind BN: Colby Rasmus BN: Matt LaPorta
SP: Johan Santana SP: Tim Lincecum SP: CC Sabathia SP: Justin Verlander SP: Erik Bedard SP: Josh Johnson RP: Matt Capps RP: Frank Francisco RP: Chad Qualls
C M Montero 1B Pujols 2B Weeks 3B Longo SS A Escobar OF Cutch, Heyward, Holliday UTIL Gordon BN B Gardner, Revere, B Hamilton
SP Strasburg CC M Moore Buccholz Parker McCarthy Iwakuma J Fernandez Cingrani Liriano Bauer Z Wheeler Pineda RP Soriano
really really good looking team you have right there
if the other owner will go for that deal, then i would do it as it really helps you out where you need it
if it were offered to me though, and i had kinsler/liriano, i probably need a little something extra to push it over the top, or someone a bit better than johnson
by footballisbetter.com » Tue Mar 10, 2009 7:56 pm
doubleplay122000 wrote:really really good looking team you have right there
if the other owner will go for that deal, then i would do it as it really helps you out where you need it
if it were offered to me though, and i had kinsler/liriano, i probably need a little something extra to push it over the top, or someone a bit better than johnson
I agree with what he said. Offer the trade and hope that he will accept it. I would probably need someone a little better than Johnson though.
I'd say Kinsler and Longoria aren't that far apart from each other in value, and if you could get Liriano while keeping CC, Johan and your other guns, that would make that stacked team look scrumptious.
"Don't worry, the fans don't start booing until July."
I couldn't get the trade I was hoping for...The current offer is Longoria for Kinsler. It is so hard to trade away the next David Wright (Longoria)... Is Kinsler worth it? Help me and I'll certainly help you...
C: Jorge Posada 1B: Albert Pujols 2B: Placido Polanco 3B: David Wright SS: Christian Guzman LF: Matt Holliday CF: Carlos Beltran RF: Vlad Guerrero UTIL: Alfonso Soriano BN: Evan Longoria BN: Carlos Quentin BN: Carlos Guillen BN: Colby Rasmus BN: Matt LaPorta
SP: Johan Santana SP: Tim Lincecum SP: CC Sabathia SP: Justin Verlander SP: Erik Bedard SP: Josh Johnson RP: Matt Capps RP: Frank Francisco RP: Chad Qualls RP: Manny Corpas
C M Montero 1B Pujols 2B Weeks 3B Longo SS A Escobar OF Cutch, Heyward, Holliday UTIL Gordon BN B Gardner, Revere, B Hamilton
SP Strasburg CC M Moore Buccholz Parker McCarthy Iwakuma J Fernandez Cingrani Liriano Bauer Z Wheeler Pineda RP Soriano
I personally would not trade Longoria for Kinsler. Longoria is going to be a monster in the future and this is a keeper league. Since you could not swing the deal for your mancrush on Liriano, I would walk away.
You can always use Quentin or someone else for an upgrade at 2B if needed in the future.
Being a keeper league, have you thought of shopping the aging Gurerro/Beltran/Soriano while you can still get some good value in return? You can look at moving one for an elite upgrade at 2B while sliding Quentin into the vacant slot. Just my $0.02 worth.
C-Doumit, Lucroy 1B- Fielder 2B-Pedroia SS-Castro 3B-Longoria CI- Lawrie MI- H. Rameriz OF-Cargo Jennings Heyward U-Morneau Markakis Brown
SP-Price Greinke Zimmerman Moore Anderson RP-Nathan McGee Doolittle Grilli