Who to keep? WHIR

[ScReWBaLLL]

I have A-rod, Reyes, Teixeira, Webb, Lincecum, and Manny Ramirez in a 10 team H2H leage with stats for R, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, TB, AVG, OPS - IP, W, CG, SV, K, HLD, ERA, WHIP, K/BB. I can keep 5 of those 6 players and I'm leaning towards having either Manny, Webb, or even Lincecum as the odd man out. It is a keeper league, but I want to win this year always so should I consider dropping Arod?? I have probably the best potential keepers in the league so this is a good problem to have, but someone please give me some input here. I don't post much but I promise that I'll know what I'm talking about when I help in return. Thanks!

[littlebilly3]

It depends on what kind of production you think ARod will give you, and if you can find someone to repace him in the interim... Personally, I would throw back either Lincecum or Webb, as I value batter more than pitcher... Thats just me though

[Carnac]

Drop Manny. The rest of your players are younger and will play hard all year!

good luck

[Kuji]

I would drop Manny. Even though he does produce, he might go into his "unhappy mood" and not produce at all.