Trade for Bruce and Votto

[Ols]

I'm trying to get Bruce from my buddy's team, and he has started out with an offer where he would be giving me both Bruce and Votto for Chris Davis and a pitcher. I have told him that I would not include Billingsley, Shields, or Greinke. Does this sound like a deal I should make or would I be better off standing pat? If yes, which pitcher should I offer?

10 team H2H Keeper
Scoring: H,R,HR,RBI,SB,AVG/W,K,SV,ERA,WHIP,CG,SHO

My Team

C Shoppach
1b MCab
2b Alexei
3b Davis
SS Drew
IF Chipper
LF Braun
CF Kemp
RF Justin Upton
OF Dunn
Util Maybin
Bench Crisp,Loney,Baker, Felipe Lopez

SP Billingsley
SP Shields
P Greinke
P Volquez
P Joba
RP Cordero
RP Valverde
Bench Baker,Slowey,Josh Johnson,Lyon

[HOOTIE]

Try Baker, then Volquez if he says no.

[cnasty]

Chris Davis is a monster could be a top 2 rounder in 2 years dont no if i would add anything to that

[HOOTIE]

Chris Davis is a monster could be a top 2 rounder in 2 years dont no if i would add anything to that

If i had to choose career, i would pick them in this order,

Bruce
Votto
Davis
Volquez/Baker

[dave knight]

I'd protect Joba, but would definitely be willing to throw out Volquez which would look like a fair deal.

[pepino]

Don't give up any of your top pitchers in that trade. Maybe Johnson. And I am surprised you have Baker on your bench. He looks like your 3rd best starter to me.