Guy will overpay for Utley: Who to trade?

[baseballwizard]

What trade can I make?

My Team
C
Ramon Hernandez
1B
Miguel Cabrera
2B
Chase Utley
3B
Aramis Ramirez
SS
Troy Tulowitzki
2B/SS
Mike Aviles
1B/3B
Adrian Gonzalez
OF
Ichiro Suzuki
OF
Carlos Quentin
OF
Adam Dunn
UTIL
Ryan Zimmerman
UTIL
Paul Konerko
P
Javier Vazquez
P
Matt Lindstrom
P
Chad Qualls\
SP
Chad Billingsley
SP
Felix Hernandez
SP
Jon Lester
RP
Jose Valverde
RP
Matt Capps
Bench
Chris Young
Bench
Pablo Sandoval
Bench
Edgar Renteria
Bench
Fausto Carmona
Bench
Rickie Weeks
Bench
Jamie Moyer

His Team
C
Jorge Posada
1B
Ryan Howard
2B
Kazuo Matsui
3B
David Wright
SS
J.J. Hardy
2B/SS
Brandon Phillips
1B/3B
Lance Berkman
OF
Jason Bay
OF
Bobby Abreu
OF
Raul Ibanez
UTIL
David Ortiz
UTIL
Jacoby Ellsbury
P
Derek Lowe
P
Joel Hanrahan
P
Mike Gonzalez
SP
Roy Oswalt
SP
Rich Harden
SP
Justin Verlander
RP
Kerry Wood
RP
Brandon Lyon
Bench
Johnny Damon
Bench
Jim Thome
Bench
Clayton Kershaw
Bench
Edwin Encarnacion
Bench
Chris Volstad
Bench
Gavin Floyd

[doubleplay122000]

id see if i could get phillips/lowe/ibanez for utley and someone you dot care too much about

phillips is still a solid 2B, you need some SP help to me (someone that is just solid) and another OF bat wouldnt kill you, esp to play over Zim at util

[baseballwizard]

hows ortiz and harden for utley

[WyldStallyn]

with the news that utley will probably be ready for opening day, overpaying would be getting back a top 5 player. an even trade would be getting back a top 20 player. ortiz and harden? no thanks

[baseballwizard]

so is anyone on his team good enough

[WyldStallyn]

so is anyone on his team good enough

wright would be nice but not realistic (unless you seriously think he'll 'overpay') howard would be fair, but im not really a fan. berkman+phillips for utley+ would work, but you really dont need to make a trade. no big holes on your team IMO

[baseballwizard]

ahhh well he offered me one more

ortiz n kaz for tulo and vazquez

[zippytrash]

so is anyone on his team good enough

wright would be nice but not realistic (unless you seriously think he'll 'overpay') howard would be fair, but im not really a fan. berkman+phillips for utley+ would work, but you really dont need to make a trade. no big holes on your team IMO

Wyld makes some very good points.... i think it would be wise to stay put unless he'll part with wright.

[baseballwizard]

yea i see he wont do that but how about ortiz n kaz for tulo and vazquez?

[baseballwizard]

anyone on this most recent trade?