Keeper Advice: Votto vs. Bruce

[flbtank]

need some help in determining the better keeper between Votto and Jay Bruce...terms are bruce is a 10th this year and 7th next year...votto is a 15th this year and 12th next year...5x5 plus OBP.

my other keeper is stephen drew and iwamura...

thanks in advance.

[mak1277]

Keep 'em both and throw back Aki.

[flbtank]

i agree in the perfect world...but i guess it was my lack of clarity here but i can acquire votto on those terms in exchange for bruce at those terms. I currently have bruce...and covet Votto

[mak1277]

I personally prefer Bruce, although the differences in draft rounds make it extremely close. I'd probably base my decision on who you think other teams will keep...will there be more 1Bs available in the draft or more OFs?

[mister_jay_peg]

Because of the round given up, I keep Votto.

[Curtis Pride]

Iwamora? WTF would you keep Iwamora? Does defense count in this fantasy league?

Votto is better than Bruce even if their round penalties were the same, especially in an OBP league, but both are way better than Iwamora.