David Price or Lastings Milledge

[Trojan Pony]

Who would you rather hang on to in a keeper league?

[HOOTIE]

I like both, but would say Price.

[MaudDib]

Price easily. Milledge has been a very frustrating player for the past few seasons. I keep expecting him to break out but it has yet to happen and if/when it does, I am not sure he will suddenly jump into the top 15 of OF. Price has the potential to be a top 5 SP as early as this year although I don't think he will pitch enough innings to get him there.

[Trojan Pony]

Yeah, but Milledge is still only 23 and showed real signs of progress last year so I'm not ready to write him off just yet... I'm leaning towards Price myself, but generally I prefer to keep hitting because it's more reliable...

[MaudDib]

I agree. He is still young and could put up some nice numbers this year. But if I was looking to keep one of the two, Price has the biggest upside. Price has the potential to be an Ace and while I generally don't keep pitchers, I think Price is a much better bet than Milledge. Last of all, Milledge would be available at the end of most drafts where Price is probably going to go in the middle rounds.