Holliday, Beltran, or Longoria?(WHIR)

[The Artful Dodger]

Beltran
Holliday
Longoria

...in that order.

Longoria first,
Holliday would be my second choice for sure.

I'd like to see Longoria prove he can sustain the unusually high FB and HR/FB rates first before ranking him at the top. He also struck out a ton during his late-season homerun binge, sacrificing his average. Plus, I'd feel comfortable falling back on Chris Davis a few rounds later. If not, Ryan Zimmerman or Adrian Beltre.

For this year, I like Beltran to bounce back and you can't discount Holliday for hitting half of the year in Oakland when it could be more of a short-term thing.

[Kimbos Beard]

In a keeper I take Longoria and Holliday.

If this was a redraft I think I would actually take Beltran, but since this is a 1st year keeper Longoria and Holliday are the better picks.