Phillips and Haren for Kinsler? (whir)

[crod8712]

H2H, 12 TEAMS, Keep all 25

Stat categories: AVG, HR, R, SB, RBI, W, ERA, WHIP, K, S

Should I deal Brandon Phillips and Dan Haren for Ian Kinsler?

Hitters:
C-Russell Martin
1B-Derrek Lee
2B-Brandon Phillips
3B-Garrett Atkins
SS-Hanley Ramirez
OF-Manny Ramirez
OF-Alexis Rios
OF-Curtis Granderson
UTIL-Chris Young

BENCH: Jorge Cantu
BENCH: Mark DeRosa
BENCH: Jeremy Hermida
BENCH: Taylor Teagarden
BENCH: Jordan Scaher
BENCH: Eric Byrnes

Starters:
C.C. Sabathia
Felix Hernandez
Dan Haren
Cliff Lee
Ricky Nolasco
Josh Johnson
Andrew Miller
Chris Volstad

Relievers:
Chad Qualls
Jonathan Broxton
Matt Lindstrom
Frank Francisco

[ayebatter]

Not me.

[Elsy]

I would, Kinsler is right up there with Utley and you have the SP depth to handle losing Haren.

[Eagle Baseball]

not me. you are going from the #3/4 2B to the #1/2 2B so the upgrade while it is an upgrade is not a significant upgrade. not enough of an upgrade to give up the #7-10 SP.

[crod8712]

What about Cliff Lee instead of Haren. So it owuld be Lee and Phillips for kinsler.

[gkrake]

I still wouldn't do it for Lee instead of Haren. I just don't think the move from Phillips to Kinsler is that drastic. Unless you're in love with Kinsler and can't stand Phillips (which is a recipe for losing in fantasy sports: man-love). I just think you'd be better off sticking with what you've got and dominating pitching cats.

Help with mine? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370909

[Matt_Domsic]

Wouldn't do that trade. Ever. You got a pretty nice team as is.

[asquad89]

Don't do it. Phillips is still up there with the top couple 2B, and Haren is too much of an ace to give up for a bump at a hitting position.

help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370919

[thatguysound]

I agree - its too much to give up. If you can substitute Haren for someone considerably less impressive, go for it. But your team is strong. Don't make a trade just to make a trade.

[kidsilk]

I wouldn't do it either even with Lee instead of Haren. Kinsler is great but Phillips isnt a slacker either.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=370915