McLouth or Wang? Keeper decision.

[converge241]

if i wasnt clear by the way i like mclouth over everyone in question

[jmurphy_j]

If you can't trade him, you definitely need to keep Martin. I don't see anybody else on your roster you should keep instead of him.

I also agree that Meche is actually better than Wang, but Meche isn't close to being a keeper. I don't think it's even close...McLouth and Atkins are much better options. Besides, when in doubt always choose the hitter over a pitcher.

[HOOTIE]

McLouth
Furcal over KRod

[duckmonkey]

McLouth
Furcal over KRod

WOW. That's a surprising one.

I do not expect 62 saves again, maybe 45-50...but I can't justify keeping someone coming off a back surgery and needs to run for value over the best closer in the Majors last year.


Thanks for the reply though!