Trade Berkman??

[amarlls]

I got offered torri hunter and quentin for my Berkman. Should I do this or counter with a guy like Votto instead of hunter?
5x5 Roto
Soto, Geovany C
Suzuki, Kurt C
Berkman, Lance 1B
Phillips, Brandon 2B
Rodriguez, Alex 3B
Aviles, Mike SS
Polanco, Placido 2B
Delgado, Carlos 1B
Crawford, Carl LF
Drew, J.D. RF
Ethier, Andre RF
Ibanez, Raul LF
Rios, Alex RF
Span, Denard RF

Active Pitchers
Hoffman, Trevor RP
Jimenez, Ubaldo SP
Jurrjens, Jair SP
Kazmir, Scott SP
Lilly, Ted SP
Santana, Ervin SP
Santana, Johan SP
Street, Huston RP
Verlander, Justin SP

Reserve Batters
Jacobs, Mike 1B
Taveras, Willy CF

Reserve Pitchers
Bonderman, Jeremy SP
Meche, Gil SP
Percival, Troy RP
Price, David SP

[amarlls]

anyone?

[amarlls]

i was thinkin my berkman drew for his quentin votto and gallardo??

[APAP]

If you could some way swing that it's great for you, although it may be asking a little too much from him. With your first deal I'm not too high on getting Hunter back in return so if you could do Votto/Quentin for Berkman I'd do it. Quentin isn't guaranteed to repeat last year's numbers so I do think you need someone like Votto to go along with him as Berkman is extremely proven.

[etex211]

Thanks for helping on mine....

I think the difference between Quentin and Berkman will not be all that great. I would only do the deal if I feel that I need another outfielder (Hunter). If he fills a need, then it could make some sense.

[GiantsFan14]

i'd make it, i don't think theres much of a difference between berkman and quentin, and hunter still has a good amount of value.

[bigrufus]

Do it! Quentin will out perform Berkman this year and Hunter is a real good throw in.

[asquad89]

If you can get him to do the deal including Drew and YoGa it's a good deal. Otherwise I'd hold off, actually. Berk typically has big-time stats to start seasons, so you may be able to bring in even more once the season starts. I like your OF as is with the exception of Drew, really. See if he wants Delgado, maybe?

help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370919