Now he wants to swap Catchers...

[APAP]

I gotta say I do like this one a lot better. After offering two closer swaps, he now offered his Mauer for my Soto. How about this one? Althou Soto offers more in power, Mauer is more realiable and is better all around. Should I take it?

[Les Straker's Toast]

I'm a huge Twins fan but I'd stay with Soto.

[Kimbos Beard]

It depends on your roster. I think I take Mauer unless your team really lacks power.

[MMBosstones86]

mauer is the better catcher right now....soto might be a little better in a few years....

but i'd rather take mauer...i think the twins are going to have a great year

[APAP]

Power wise I'm loaded:

10 teams h2h
Full $$$ Dynasty
ALL MINORS IN FA POOL MUST BE ADDED TO ROSTER
c Geovany Soto
1b Prince Fielder
2b Brandon Phillips
3b Edwin Encarnacion
ss Jose Reyes
ci Miguel Cabrera
mi Rickie Weeks
lf Alfonso Soriano
cf BJ Upton
rf Justin Upton
util Carlos Lee
util David Ortiz

bn James Loney
bn Rick Ankiel
bn Adam Lind
bn Denard Span
bn Andy LaRoche
bn Pedro Alvarez (R)
bn Max Rodriguez (R)
bn Chris Carter (R)
bn Greg Halman (R)

sp Jake Peavy
sp Felix Hernandez
sp Yovani Gallardo
sp Adam Wainwright
sp Clayton Kershaw
sp Brandon Morrow
sp Jeremy Guthrie
sp Brad Penny
sp Ian Snell
rp Joakim Soria
rp Jonathan Broxton
rp Bobby Jenks
sp Rick Porcello (R)
sp Neftali Feliz (R)
sp Tommy Hanson (R)
sp Jhoulys Chacin (R)
sp Sean West (R)

Minor League Farm System
1) Mike Moustakas
2) Jeremy Hellickson
3) Yorman Rodriguez
4) Engel Beltre
5) Ethan Martin
6) Casey Weathers
7) Brett Lawrie
8) Nick Weglarz
9) Jordan Walden

[amarlls]

With the power you have id get Mauer way more consistent and seasoned

viewtopic.php?t=370764

[Elsy]

Go with Mauer

[APAP]

Thanks guys.

[HOOTIE]

I like Soto. I don't see Mauer catching in a few years.

[ayebatter]

I like Soto. I don't see Mauer catching in a few years.

I'd agree with you on Mauer, but I'll worry 'bout that when the time comes. Take Mauer.