Rank these 1B for a keeper draft

[djacks]

14 team keeper league in our 10th year...I need a 1B and am targeting one in the first or second round (we keep 7 + 2 prospects)...

C. Delgado
J. Cantu
J. Loney
C. Jackson
C. Pena

I think Loney has some upside, but Pena or Delgado might be better for this year. It's a points league, not roto, but it tends to value players about the same as a 5x5 league would.

Thanks!...WHIR

[pepino]

Very close with all five. I give Loney the edge just because he is younger and has more room to improve.

Loney
Delgado
Pena
Jackson
Cantu

[HOOTIE]

14 team keeper league in our 10th year...I need a 1B and am targeting one in the first or second round (we keep 7 + 2 prospects)...

2 C. Delgado
4 J. Cantu
1 J. Loney
5 C. Jackson
3 C. Pena

I think Loney has some upside, but Pena or Delgado might be better for this year. It's a points league, not roto, but it tends to value players about the same as a 5x5 league would.

Thanks!...WHIR

[Tenacious D-Store]

I'm surprised to see Loney ranked at #1 by two people so far. I agree tough, I think Loney will be better than Votto and is a huge steal. He my not have a lot of power but he's a great gap hitter. Think Lyle Overbay the season he won the Doubles Title.

Loney
Pena
Delgado
Cantu
Jackson

[OneLoveBoomer]

Pena
Loney
Delgado
...
...

[Elsy]

Loney
Delgado(maybe two years left but prolly one)
Pena