Loney vs Pelfrey...Keeper question

[jmurphy_j]

I would keep Loney.

You mentioned your concerns re: Chris Davis, which are valid. But more importantly you have Chipper at 3B. Chipper's great when he play's, but you know he is going to spend some time on the DL (he always does). That means you will likely need to play Davis at 3B for a significant portion of the season....thus making it even more important that you get another 1B.

Besides, when in doubt, always pick a hitter over a pitcher.

[ttor68]

Those that picked Loney...what is it about Loney that you like? I kept him last year because I thought the September before he finally started developping power, but then last year his power numbers were poor.