Trade salty-dukes?

[bigrufus]

Who gets the better end of the deal --Salty or Dukes? 5x5 roto. Both players are going to bench guys so maybe the question should be who has a better chance of breaking out. Thanks

[Neato Torpedo]

If you have a good #1 catcher than Dukes, easily.

[doubleplay122000]

it is a little difficult to say without seeing your roster...if you are confident with your catching position then dukes is the guy to go with, otherwise you stick with salty

if you are looking for a better breakout candidate, then i think i go salty anyway, given he will probably get more ABs (i dont see Dukes staying on the field all season for one reason or another)

[bigrufus]

Dukes drives me nuts because he is off the wall and salty drives me nuts because he hasn't lived up to the to his potential-yet! Thanks for the help