Kinsler for Derosa and Carlos Lee

[Nine_Drunks]

I've been offered Derosa and Carlos Lee for Ian Kinsler... It looks like the numbers between Kinsler and Derosa are close expect for SB and I get Carlos Lee... I'm torn and need some input...

[birdbrains]

I like it a lot...kinsler is the best player of the 3....I would grab it quick

please look at mine
thanks
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370582

[sreill]

I think Lee is the best player in tha deal right now. Take it

[sman]

I would do that deal, it seems like you're getting equal to greater value for Kinsler.

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=370654

[tianyi86]

I completely disagree with you guys and would glady keep kinsler. Kinsler put up his numbers in 112games. Extend it to 140+ games and he blows out Derosa + Carlos Lee combined. And if you look at Derosa's numbers, last year was the anomaly for his career, especially in the power department. Keep Kinsler or shop him around for better offers.

[birdbrains]

I agree...I like kinsler better...as I stated before...but when I said grab it quick I was thinking you would get kinsler...
dont trade away kinsler

[jake_twothousandfive]

Don't do this. Before last year DeRosa hadn't come close to 20 HRs in a season, and his 6 SBs where also a career high (plus he has never hit over .300 in any season). At 34 years old, I highly doubt he'll be able to repeat his breakout numbers from last season. He's nothing more than a lower level fantasy second basemen this year...a boarderline starter in most leagues.

I like Carlos Lee a lot, but based on positions Kinsler has a lot more value. Keep what you've got.