Keeper draft help....whir

[Elsy]

In the first round (18th round after keepers) any thoughts on my pick (9th)?

Current Roster:

C - J. Mauer
1B - A. Gonzalez
2B - C. Utley
SS - J. Rollins
3B - S. Rolen
OF - R. Ludwick/V. Wells/C. Lee
Util - M. Aviles(2B/SS)/N. Cruz(OF)
BN - C. Dickerson(OF)

SP - R. Halladay/B. Webb/D. Purcey
RP - B.J. Ryan/B. Ziegler/B. Lyon


Who should still be there around my pick:

X. Nady, B. Lyon(closer in DET), E. Byrnes, K. Fukudome, K. Kawakami,

[birdbrains]

go with the closer lyon at this point, next would be fukodome

please look at mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370582

[Elsy]

Any other thoughts?

[eazyb81]

I'm not confident that Lyons will stick as Detroit's closer, so I would go with more of a sure thing with Nady, as he will get the playing time.

Here's mine, thanks.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370668

[Elsy]

I was originally thinking Nady as well but then started looking and saw Lyon. Even with having 5 OF's already, should go with another one?

[birdbrains]

last i checked lyon is in the lead for the closer....but the thing is with closers...you can draft none and if you watch closers closely you can always pick them up during yr as they change often
but i would still go with lyon as you have a better chance using him as trade bait if he is a closer and there is always one or 2 teams desparate for a closer

[Elsy]

Looks as though Percival, H Matsui, Drew will be there as well. Thought someone might have grabbed these guys before me that is why I didn't list them earlier. Any better than Lyon? More than likely between Percival and Lyon as my OF is already full, thanks for all input so far.