Keeper/Trade Help Needed (WHIR)

[wheels]

10 team hth keeper (no term limit) league with traditional offensive/pitching categories.

My other keepers are...
DH:Pujols
C:Doumit
1B:Teixeira
2B:Alexi Ramirez (or Cano)
SS:Rollins
3B:Longoria
OF:CLee, McLouth, Bruce (or Mags)
SP:JSantana, Sabathia
RP:Rodriguez (or Lidge/Soria)

Would you trade FRod & McLouth for BJ Upton and keep Lidge or Soria instead?

Leave a link, WHIR for sure!

[Holein1]

for sure do that...upton will be a top 3 of

I like soria more than lidge for a keeper

please help

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370607

[Yank3ez]

yep I'd do it, I expect Upton's power numbers to rebound this year and I think F-Rod's value is down alot being on the Mets, and Lidge and Soria would be solid closer options instead

Thanks for the help with mine

[NRobinson]

Without a question. Closers are a dime a dozen, and Upton is the better OF by a mile.

[asquad89]

I'll echo previous posts and say get Upton while you can. I trust the whole "dont pay for saves" theory (for all we know, JJ Putz is the Mets closer in a year or two -- maybe sooner) and thus this makes the deal favorable for ya.

thanks for the help with mine.

[NittanyLions1]

Yup, I agree with everyone else on this one...get Upton. I would keep Soria over Lidge probably but its close

[sman]

Yes, I would do that deal and keep Soria. Thank you for the help with mine.

[sox 06]

I like the deal. Upton will be a stud very soon and I also like Soria over Lidge. Thanks for your help with mine.

[broomulack]

I'd do it in a heartbeat. Upton is much better than McLouth, and I think Soria and Lidge may be better options that K-Rod straight up. It's close enough to debate, so do the deal.

[Elsy]

Put another on the board. When I first read it I thought there would be more saying keep K-Rod, especially after last year. But I have to agree that in a keeper Upton's potential makes this worth it for you.