Rank these 5 OF

[cubbieball10]

I have them in the following order:

Raul Ibanez (Mr. Reliable)
Chris B. Young (20/25 potential if you can swallow the BA)
Andre Ethier (last Torre lineup I saw projected Ethier to bat 3rd to Manny's cleanup)
Lastings Milledge (20/20--poor man's Chris Young--with a higher BA)
Jayson Werth (don't see him duplicating last years numbers)

Where would you rank these guys?

[colt4523]

I have them just like you have them listed
Raul Ibanez
Chris B. Young
Andre Ethier
Lastings Milledge
Jayson Werth

[smoovethug]

Werth
Milledge
Ibanez
Ethier
Young

[cubbieball10]

I'm curious what the impulse is for putting Werth and Milledge so high, and being so down on Chris Young. Or is it just a gut instinct?

[HOOTIE]

Ethier
Milledge
Werth
Ibanez
Young

[kidsilk]

Milledge(should break out this year)
Werth
Ethier
Ibanez
Young

[astromania]

Ethier
Werth
Ibanez
Milledge (will be totally surprised, if he finally has his "breakout year")
Young

[Svatos]

Ethier
Ibanez
Werth
Milledge
Young

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=370569

[JMoney]

Ethier
Milledge
Werth
Young
Ibanez

[The River]

Ethier (Have to love the Dodgers lineup this season, Either is surrounded by young and productive talent along with Manny being Manny)

Ibanez (3 straight season with 100+ RBIs and add the fact he is now in the dangerous Phillies lineup, I'd expect similar numbers to last season if not better, but don't expect as much power)

Young (I'd expect his average to rise somewhat this season, it's my make or break year for him, give me .270 and I'm satisfied)

Milledge (In a lineup headlined by Dunn and Zimmerman, I'd expect Lastings to see a boost in his numbers, but not enough to make the jump over Young or Ibanez or Ethier)

Werth (I wouldn't put him in the same category of OF with the four above him that you listed. I don't expect nearly as good stats as last season, which was his first season of any serious production AT ALL)