i would keep davis, his ceiling is possibley very high. that and you keep your 19th pick makes it an easy decision for me. short term i don't see much of a downside picking davis anyway, his avg will be about the same, you will lose the SB's but certainly pick up some HR's.
I agree Hart is safer, but I like to gamble. Davis as a 23rd round pick has the potential to be the biggest steal of your entire league. Even if he does half of what he's expected to do he's still more valuable than a pick you would get in that round. Go for it.
personally, i like Hart. the 19th rd is great value too and he is a proven 20/20 guy. i guess i haven't seen enough of davis to be on the bandwagon as hard as everyone else. yes he's got huge power upside but i just don't know enough about him yet. also i'm an admitted hart guy.
i like Hart over Davis but you can't go wrong with either. with the depth in of, you may have an easier time getting productive numbers if you go Davis for this season. good to plan for the future but need to win now. viewtopic.php?t=370545
Do you need 3B help? Davis is more valuable due to position scarcity than Hart.......and hopefully will play enough 3B to retain eligibility for next year.......Davis is young and has Hamiliton breakout potiental this year in that crazy Ranger lineup.