Failed 5-Tool OFs

[King Tim]

Alex Escobar, NYM

[Havok1517]

Alex Escobar, NYM

nice one...Jody Gerut comes to mind as well.

[bigken117]

I don't think Jeremy Reed ever had power as a tool...

[Field]

Rocco Baldelli?

[Havok1517]

Rocco Baldelli?

I'd say yes as he got Dimaggio comparisons.

[Guaranteed Loser]

Alex Escobar, NYM

nice one...Jody Gerut comes to mind as well.

Jody put together a surprising decent season last year. He might just squeeze in a decent 2 or 3 years.

[RyanK]

Ben Grieve... seemed i got his rookie card ever pack of baseball cards when i was younger

[AussieDodger]

I'd say J.D Drew in a way.

He was supposed to be the next coming of christ, and injuries have derailed him to an extent.
He's still an amazing real-life hitter, but fantasy-wise meh.

[CadensDad]

I'd say J.D Drew in a way.

He was supposed to be the next coming of christ, and injuries have derailed him to an extent.
He's still an amazing real-life hitter, but fantasy-wise meh.

What look at all that money he has got, you tell me he's not all he's "paid" to be?

[hot4tx]

Jason Tyner.

Former 1st rd pick (#21 by the Mets in '98) that should have had massive power (can hit the ball 300 feet in BP) to go along with his other 4 tools. Managed only 4 HR's in 4700 MLB and MiLB AB's. Crashed and burned.

note - I am joking

BOOOOOOO!!!! Go easy, I went to school with Tyner.