mclouth or bj upton

[shobocop]

i have the #4 overall pick in the 2nd year of a keeper league

my 5 current guys are: reyes, carlos lee, longoria, prince and halladay

upton and mclouth are available and will most likely drop to my spot in the draft .

which should i go for, i like upton becase of the power he showed in the postseason last year after his injury and he is in a much better lineup

but mclouth is a beast too.

hamels is also available but i dont want to take a pitcher so high

any thoughts?

[footballisbetter.com]

I am a big fan of Mclouth, but you HAVE to take Upton in that spot. Upton has a ton more upside.

[C2ThaLo88]

Definitely Upton

[Johnny Tuttle]

For me, it's Upton by a mile.

McLouth had a couple of good months last year. I'm very skeptical.

[Texas Flats]

Upton >>>>>>> McLouth. I wouldn't think twice about taking Upton in that spot.

[rupertoooo]

Not even close, Upton here.