CRAZY Trade Offer (WHIR)

[reblaze369]

I was offered Pujols, Hawpe, Peralta and V Mart for my Reyes, Carlos Lee, McCann and Votto. Should I do it??? Thoughts???

My 10 team h2h league team

McCann, Brian C
Votto, Joey 1B
Kinsler, Ian 2B
Davis, Chris 3B
Reyes, Jose B. SS
Beltran, Carlos CF
Dunn, Adam LF
Lee, Carlos N. LF
Dye, Jermaine RF

Active Pitchers
Billingsley, Chad SP
Garza, Matt SP
Scherzer, Max SP
Vazquez, Javier SP
Volquez, Edinson SP
Broxton, Jonathan RP
Valverde, Jose RP

Reserve Batters
Aviles, Mike SS
Cruz, Nelson R. RF

Reserve Pitchers
Perez, Oliver SP
Young, Chris R. SP
Francisco, Frank RP

(HIS Team)

Martinez, Victor C
Pujols, Albert 1B
Cano, Robinson 2B
Longoria, Evan 3B
Young, Michael SS
Guerrero, Vladimir RF
Hawpe, Brad RF
Suzuki, Ichiro RF
Ortiz, David DH

Active Pitchers
Cain, Matt SP
Lackey, John SP
Lester, Jon SP
Verlander, Justin SP
Wainwright, Adam SP
Capps, Matt RP
Jenks, Bobby RP

Reserve Batters
Cantu, Jorge 3B
Peralta, Jhonny SS

Reserve Pitchers
Bedard, Erik SP SEA
Carpenter, Chris SP STL
Johnson, Randy SP

[Tenacious D-Store]

Wow, why not just switch teams? This deal looks pointless. I personally don't even consider giant 8 player trades like this. Guys who offer these trades are just looking to trade because they think it's fun. Collecting baseball cards would be a more advisable hobby for them. Pass, it does nothing for either of you.

[Hummus]

I agree. Granted, I have a 6-player trade posted for discussion, but here there is not even a slight advantage to be gained in making this trade. You are giving up a top five pick for a top five pick (Reyes is hugely valuable in h2h), and then:

Lee > Hawpe
McCann > VMart (will bounce back, this year, however)
Votto (going to break out even more this year) > Peralta

I do not see why you would consider something like this.