Nelson Cruz or Justin Upton?

[Jakra]

5x5 Roto League. Edwin Encarnacion is a FA and I'd like to drop one of my OF to make room for him. Which one?

C - Sandoval
1B - Teixeira
2B - K Johnson
3B - MCab
SS - A Ramirez
OF - Crawford, Markakis, Damon
UT - Ibanez
BN - Cruz, Upton

SP - Haren, Billingsley, Lackey, F Hernandez, Shields, Harang, Scherzer
RP - Broxton, Capps, Perez

[Tenacious D-Store]

This year, Cruz
Long term, Upton

[gore51]

Cruz, worried about Upton being able to hit away from AZ (home-away splits are terrible)
Statistic G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
Home 57 190 37 61 13 5 12 32 27 57 1 3 .321 .407 .632 1.039
Away 51 166 15 28 6 1 3 10 27 64 0 1 .169 .291 .271 .562

[DaShiz23]

This year, Cruz
Long term, Upton

helluva team, BTW.

[denicola_dominates]

hmmmm interesting decision id take upton for longterm and shorttem i would definitely pick upton both times

[cnote23]

Upton now and Upton tomorrow.

[HOOTIE]

Neither. I would cut Harang or Damon. Cruz is batting 4th, no way drop him.

[Grounded Polo]

I'd cut Cruz but do you really need EE? He'd just be a platoon guy at UTIL for you with Miggy and Tex at 1B/3B.

[The Artful Dodger]

I would stick with both Cruz and Upton. No need to have EE on board when you already have M-Cab covering at third.

[ayebatter]

Neither. I would cut Harang or Damon. Cruz is batting 4th, no way drop
him.

Agreed here, keep Cruz & Upton, I'd guess this is a keeper so MCab won't be 3b eligible next yr and you would like to see Edwin at 3b in the future - cut Damon or Harang for Edwin.