Which 2 pitchers for B. Webb?

[Hawkeye1]

This is a roto keeper league, standard scoring. Our keepers (7 per season) count as the round they were originally drafted in. Which of these pitchers would you absolutely NOT trade in a 2 for 1 deal to acquire Webb (4th round)?
Oswalt (2nd round)
C. Billingsley (10th round)
R. Nolasco (10th round)
A. J. Burnett (11th round)
J. Lester (22nd round)
Cliff Lee (29th)

[bearhunter17]

I like NAtional League pitchers so I would keep Oswalt and Nolasco.

[ensanimal]

Based on value Lester and Lee are by far the 2 that I would not trade.

[Johnny Tuttle]

Crap. I lost my reply.

Billingsley is the best on the list. Nolasco might very well be #2.

For a second rounder, I pack Oswalt's bags for him.

Lee is a wild card at that round value, but I don't see him ever approaching 2008 again. Lester's the tough one here. He's potentially bumping Nolasco, esp. with his round being much, much lower.

Check out http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/index. ... antasy-ace.

[bauermj]

I would go Billingsley & Lester.


See ya Roy at that 2nd rd pick

[Grounded Polo]

Billingsley and Lester. Oswalt is worthless when kept as a second round pick, horribly overvalued. I don't think any pair of the other guys would land Webb though. Cliff Lee being basically free might get it done when a 4th rounder for Webb is normal value.

[APAP]

Gotta go Bills/Lester although I'd prefer Webb over any of them.

[ayebatter]

I'd move Oswalt & Lee for Webb. Oswalt in the 2nd isn't a keeper, so that would really make the trade Webb 4th for Lee 29th.

[j24jags]

I'd definitely try to keep Lester/Lee/Bills