Your keeper list looks alot like mine (Howard, MCab, Kinsler, Sizemore, Hamilton, Manny, Hamels)...it's nice being on top, huh?
Anyway, I'd definitely make this deal, I think there's a TON of mid-round value at SP (guys like Nolasco, Gallardo, Scherzer, etc) and Peavy's peripherals last year (and the injury) make me wonder if he's starting to show some wear.
That offense will be utterly dominant, then you can build your pitching staff in the mid rounds. Good luck!
Any help here?viewtopic.php?t=369802