TOP 10 for AL Only 5x5 Head-to-Head???

[deuce315]

Lets see some rankings for AL only head to head league with standard 5x5 scoring.

[dave knight]

Never mind.

[j24jags]

Sizemore
Hamilton
Quentin
Holliday
Markakis
Upton
Bay
Vlad
Ichiro
Rios

The last spot is by far the toughest; you could make an argument for 7 or 8 players there.

The top 4 are the clear best in class.

You forgot ARod?

I think ARod goes at the top...

[pre1322]

And Miggy...can't forget MCab

[j24jags]

And Miggy...can't forget MCab

Good catch, MCab is #2

[Tenacious D-Store]

I just did a 5x5 AL only draft this morning. I'll post the results if it helps any. Keep in mind this particular league uses 2 catchers, a middle and corner infielder as well as 5 OF spots and 2 utility spots. No lectures about my team name... "Cory Lidle Flight School" Isn't funny, I got enough of that from some pissed off Yankees fan. Some people are a bit over-sensitive.

Round 1
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Sizemore, Grady CF CLE
2 nyc2009 Rodriguez, Alex 3B NYY
3 Team Blaze Hamilton, Josh CF TEX
4 cats Sabathia, CC SP NYY
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Holliday, Matt LF OAK
6 Damn Yankees Pedroia, Dustin 2B BOS
7 dinktheman Cabrera, Miguel 1B DET
8 Look Ma No Steroids Teixeira, Mark 1B NYY
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Morneau, Justin 1B MIN
10 the mariners Longoria, Evan 3B TB
Round 2
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Upton, B.J. CF TB
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Quentin, Carlos LF CHW
3 Look Ma No Steroids Halladay, Roy SP TOR
4 dinktheman Kinsler, Ian 2B TEX
5 Damn Yankees Youkilis, Kevin 1B BOS
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Papelbon, Jonathan RP BOS
7 cats Beckett, Josh SP BOS
8 Team Blaze Rivera, Mariano RP NYY
9 nyc2009 Nathan, Joe RP MIN
10 bigcats Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA
Round 3
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Lee, Cliff SP CLE
2 nyc2009 Lackey, John SP ANA
3 Team Blaze Jenks, Bobby RP CHW
4 cats Crawford, Carl LF TB
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Soria, Joakim RP KC
6 Damn Yankees Santana, Ervin SP ANA
7 dinktheman Bay, Jason LF BOS
8 Look Ma No Steroids Rios, Alex RF TOR
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Burnett, A.J. SP NYY
10 the mariners Guerrero, Vladimir RF ANA
Round 4
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Wood, Kerry RP CLE
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Markakis, Nick RF BAL
3 Look Ma No Steroids Matsuzaka, Daisuke SP BOS
4 dinktheman Kazmir, Scott SP TB
5 Damn Yankees Martinez, Victor C CLE
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Ortiz, David DH BOS
7 cats Hernandez, Felix SP SEA
8 Team Blaze Shields, James SP TB
9 nyc2009 Roberts, Brian 2B BAL
10 bigcats Ellsbury, Jacoby CF BOS
Round 5
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Lester, Jon SP BOS
2 nyc2009 Liriano, Francisco SP MIN
3 Team Blaze Granderson, Curtis CF DET
4 cats Mauer, Joe C MIN
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Ordonez, Magglio RF DET
6 Damn Yankees Figgins, Chone 3B ANA
7 dinktheman Wang, Chien-Ming SP NYY
8 Look Ma No Steroids Ramirez, Alexei 2B CHW
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Huff, Aubrey 1B BAL
10 the mariners Abreu, Bobby RF ANA
Round 6
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Jeter, Derek SS NYY
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Pena, Carlos 1B TB
3 Look Ma No Steroids Verlander, Justin SP DET
4 dinktheman Chamberlain, Joba SP NYY
5 Damn Yankees Cano, Robinson 2B NYY
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Ryan, B.J. RP TOR
7 cats Young, Michael SS TEX
8 Team Blaze Wells, Vernon CF TOR
9 nyc2009 Hunter, Torii CF ANA
10 bigcats Fuentes, Brian RP ANA
Round 7
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Weaver, Jered SP ANA
2 nyc2009 Damon, Johnny LF NYY
3 Team Blaze Dye, Jermaine RF CHW
4 cats Davis, Chris 3B TEX
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Burrell, Pat LF TB
6 Damn Yankees Carmona, Fausto SP CLE
7 dinktheman Morrow, Brandon SP SEA
8 Look Ma No Steroids Price, David SP TB
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Gomez, Carlos CF MIN
10 the mariners Devine, Joey RP OAK
Round 8
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Bedard, Erik SP SEA
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Greinke, Zack SP KC
3 Look Ma No Steroids Ziegler, Brad RP OAK
4 dinktheman Danks, John SP CHW
5 Damn Yankees Cabrera, Orlando SS CHW
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Saunders, Joe SP ANA
7 cats DeRosa, Mark 2B CLE
8 Team Blaze Crisp, Coco CF KC
9 nyc2009 Garza, Matt SP TB
10 bigcats Slowey, Kevin SP MIN
Round 9
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Floyd, Gavin SP CHW
2 nyc2009 Nady, Xavier RF NYY
3 Team Blaze Peralta, Jhonny SS CLE
4 cats Wieters, Matt C BAL
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Sonnanstine, Andy SP TB
6 Damn Yankees Drew, J.D. RF BOS
7 dinktheman Baker, Scott SP MIN
8 Look Ma No Steroids Pettitte, Andy SP NYY
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Francisco, Frank RP TEX
10 the mariners Young, Delmon LF MIN
Round 10
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Matsui, Hideki LF NYY
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Lopez, Jose 2B SEA
3 Look Ma No Steroids Gordon, Alex 3B KC
4 dinktheman Guillen, Carlos 3B DET
5 Damn Yankees Shields, Scot RP ANA
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Lowell, Mike 3B BOS
7 cats Konerko, Paul 1B CHW
8 Team Blaze Span, Denard RF MIN
9 nyc2009 Penny, Brad SP BOS
10 bigcats Cruz, Nelson R. RF TEX
Round 11
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Aviles, Mike SS KC
2 nyc2009 Polanco, Placido 2B DET
3 Team Blaze Jacobs, Mike 1B KC
4 cats Thome, Jim DH CHW
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Giambi, Jason 1B OAK
6 Damn Yankees Choo, Shin-Soo RF CLE
7 dinktheman Meche, Gil SP KC
8 Look Ma No Steroids Hafner, Travis DH CLE
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Beltre, Adrian 3B SEA
10 the mariners Kendrick, Howie 2B ANA
Round 12
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Swisher, Nick CF NYY
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Jones, Adam CF BAL
3 Look Ma No Steroids Buehrle, Mark SP CHW
4 dinktheman Bonderman, Jeremy SP DET
5 Damn Yankees Pierzynski, A.J. C CHW
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Duchscherer, Justin SP OAK
7 cats Ray, Chris RP BAL
8 Team Blaze Kubel, Jason LF MIN
9 nyc2009 Cuddyer, Michael RF MIN
10 bigcats DeJesus, David LF KC
Round 13
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Blalock, Hank 1B TEX
2 nyc2009 Garko, Ryan 1B CLE
3 Team Blaze Mora, Melvin 3B BAL
4 cats Guillen, Jose RF KC
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Butler, Billy 1B KC
6 Damn Yankees Freel, Ryan P. CF BAL
7 dinktheman Scott, Luke LF BAL
8 Look Ma No Steroids Hill, Aaron 2B TOR
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Lind, Adam LF TOR
10 the mariners Lowrie, Jed SS BOS
Round 14
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Galarraga, Armando SP DET
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Lyon, Brandon RP DET
3 Look Ma No Steroids Percival, Troy RP TB
4 dinktheman Murphy, David RF TEX
5 Damn Yankees Litsch, Jesse SP TOR
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Overbay, Lyle 1B TOR
7 cats LaPorta, Matt OF CLE
8 Team Blaze Sherrill, George RP BAL
9 nyc2009 Francisco, Ben LF CLE
10 bigcats Byrd, Marlon CF TEX
Round 15
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Arredondo, Jose RP ANA
2 nyc2009 Shoppach, Kelly C CLE
3 Team Blaze Wigginton, Ty 3B BAL
4 cats Cust, Jack LF OAK
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Posada, Jorge C NYY
6 Damn Yankees Jones, Andruw CF TEX
7 dinktheman Griffey, Ken RF SEA
8 Look Ma No Steroids Baldelli, Rocco DH BOS
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Andrus, Elvis SS TEX
10 the mariners Betancourt, Yuniesky SS SEA
Round 16
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Balfour, Grant RP TB
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Navarro, Dioner C TB
3 Look Ma No Steroids Sheffield, Gary DH DET
4 dinktheman Saltalamacchia, Jarrod C TEX
5 Damn Yankees Teahen, Mark RF KC
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Smoltz, John SP BOS
7 cats Crosby, Bobby SS OAK
8 Team Blaze Inge, Brandon 3B DET
9 nyc2009 Reyes, Anthony SP CLE
10 bigcats Rivera, Juan L. LF ANA
Round 17
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Joyce, Matt OF TB
2 nyc2009 Snider, Travis OF TOR
3 Team Blaze Gutierrez, Franklin RF SEA
4 cats Zumaya, Joel RP DET
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Bartlett, Jason SS TB
6 Damn Yankees Napoli, Mike C ANA
7 dinktheman Ellis, Mark 2B OAK
8 Look Ma No Steroids Thames, Marcus LF DET
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Casilla, Alexi 2B MIN
10 the mariners Iwamura, Akinori 2B TB
Round 18
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Guthrie, Jeremy SP BAL
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Laird, Gerald C DET
3 Look Ma No Steroids Jackson, Edwin SP DET
4 dinktheman Padilla, Vicente SP TEX
5 Damn Yankees McCarthy, Brandon SP TEX
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Aybar, Erick SS ANA
7 cats Masterson, Justin SP BOS
8 Team Blaze Harris, Brendan SS MIN
9 nyc2009 Suzuki, Kurt C OAK
10 bigcats Sweeney, Ryan RF OAK
Round 19
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Sweeney, Mike DH SEA
2 nyc2009 Wakefield, Tim SP BOS
3 Team Blaze Millwood, Kevin SP TEX
4 cats Millar, Kevin 1B TOR
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Perkins, Glen SP MIN
6 Damn Yankees Wheeler, Dan RP TB
7 dinktheman Wood, Brandon 3B ANA
8 Look Ma No Steroids Chavez, Eric 3B OAK
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Uehara, Koji RP BAL
10 the mariners Izturis, Maicer SS ANA
Round 20
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Hughes, Phil SP NYY
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Blackburn, Nick SP MIN
3 Look Ma No Steroids Betemit, Wilson 1B CHW
4 dinktheman Fields, Josh D. 3B CHW
5 Damn Yankees Crede, Joe 3B MIN
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Ka'aihue, Kila DH KC
7 cats Davis, Rajai CF OAK
8 Team Blaze Shealy, Ryan 1B KC
9 nyc2009 Saito, Takashi RP BOS
10 bigcats Arias, Joaquin 2B TEX
Round 21
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Cabrera, Melky CF NYY
2 nyc2009 Barajas, Rod C TOR
3 Team Blaze German, Esteban 2B KC
4 cats Downs, Scott RP TOR
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Zaun, Gregg C BAL
6 Damn Yankees Lugo, Julio SS BOS
7 dinktheman Ramirez, Ramon RP BOS
8 Look Ma No Steroids Linebrink, Scott RP CHW
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Eveland, Dana SP OAK
10 the mariners Owens, Jerry CF CHW
Round 22
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Johnson, Jim R. RP BAL
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Rowland-Smith, Ryan SP SEA
3 Look Ma No Steroids Buck, John C KC
4 dinktheman McGowan, Dustin SP TOR
5 Damn Yankees Cabrera, Asdrubal 2B CLE
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Varitek, Jason C BOS
7 cats Laffey, Aaron SP CLE
8 Team Blaze Perez, Rafael RP CLE
9 nyc2009 Rodney, Fernando RP DET
10 bigcats Colon, Bartolo SP CHW
Round 23
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Gardner, Brett CF NYY
2 nyc2009 Rolen, Scott 3B TOR
3 Team Blaze Richard, Clayton SP CHW
4 cats Bard, Josh C BOS
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Okajima, Hideki RP BOS
6 Damn Yankees Howell, J.P. RP TB
7 dinktheman Willits, Reggie LF ANA
8 Look Ma No Steroids Johjima, Kenji C SEA
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Lewis, Jensen RP CLE
10 the mariners Accardo, Jeremy RP TOR
Round 24
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Ramirez, Max C TEX
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Carlson, Jesse RP TOR
3 Look Ma No Steroids Morales, Kendry OF ANA
4 dinktheman Teagarden, Taylor C TEX
5 Damn Yankees Kottaras, George C BOS
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Matthews, Gary RF ANA
7 cats Marte, Damaso RP NYY
8 Team Blaze Wilson, C.J. RP TEX
9 nyc2009 Rodriguez, Ivan C NYY
10 bigcats Miner, Zach SP DET
Round 25
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Mathis, Jeff C ANA
2 nyc2009 Balentien, Wladimir RF SEA
3 Team Blaze Guardado, Eddie RP TEX
4 cats Harrison, Matt SP TEX
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Getz, Chris 2B CHW
6 Damn Yankees Betancourt, Rafael RP CLE
7 dinktheman Clement, Jeff C SEA
8 Look Ma No Steroids Bannister, Brian SP KC
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Buchholz, Clay SP BOS
10 the mariners Izturis, Cesar SS BAL
Round 26
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Zobrist, Ben SS TB
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Lowe, Mark RP SEA
3 Look Ma No Steroids Montanez, Luis LF BAL
4 dinktheman Willis, Dontrelle SP DET
5 Damn Yankees Perez, Fernando OF TB
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Barton, Daric 1B OAK
7 cats Crain, Jesse RP MIN
8 Team Blaze Olivo, Miguel C KC
9 nyc2009 Punto, Nick SS MIN
10 bigcats Bautista, Jose A. 3B TOR
Round 27
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Buscher, Brian 3B MIN
2 nyc2009 Thornton, Matt RP CHW
3 Team Blaze Dotel, Octavio RP CHW
4 cats Buck, Travis RF OAK
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Gross, Gabe RF TB
6 Damn Yankees Payton, Jay LF BAL
7 dinktheman Scutaro, Marco SS TOR
8 Look Ma No Steroids Salazar, Oscar 1B BAL
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Poreda, Aaron SP CHW
10 the mariners Grudzielanek, Mark 2B KC
Round 28
Pick Team Player
1 the mariners Patterson, Eric 2B OAK
2 Cory Lidle Flight School Purcey, David SP TOR
3 Look Ma No Steroids Inglett, Joe 2B TOR
4 dinktheman Callaspo, Alberto 2B KC
5 Damn Yankees Kennedy, Adam 2B TB
6 PASADENA PANTHERS Aybar, Willy 3B TB
7 cats Rodriguez, Sean 2B ANA
8 Team Blaze Dellucci, Dave LF CLE
9 nyc2009 LaHair, Bryan 1B SEA
10 bigcats Cedeno, Ronny SS SEA
Round 29
Pick Team Player
1 bigcats Redmond, Mike C MIN
2 nyc2009 Gload, Ross 1B KC
3 Team Blaze Barfield, Josh 2B CLE
4 cats Tolbert, Matt 3B MIN
5 PASADENA PANTHERS Coke, Phil RP NYY
6 Damn Yankees Delcarmen, Manny RP BOS
7 dinktheman Cunningham, Aaron OF OAK
8 Look Ma No Steroids Lillibridge, Brent SS CHW
9 Cory Lidle Flight School Outman, Josh SP OAK
10 the mariners Molina, Jose C NYY