BIG TRADE....PLEASE Help

[Lakers256P]

6 x 6 roto (kk/bb and OPS)

The offer is Wright Felix and Berkman

for

Sizemore Kinsler and Gallardo

Which side gets the better deal???

[Ernie.Whitt.]

My first question is why would you want to make this deal. Its not an obvious win in my mind or either side, though I would personally prefer to have Wright and co. Regardless, is it a keeper? What are your rosters? On its own it just looks too much like a trade for the sake of a trade which is something try to avoid.

[Dodgerbluesc]

Well I hardly would call exchanging a 3B/SP/1B for a OF/2B/SP a trade for the sake of trading, so don't worry about that at all.

Clearly Wright is the best player in the deal. That said I feel that Berkman is replaceable and I would definitely take Sizemore/Kinsler/Gallardo here. More details would help - but pretty much regardless of what the details are I'm sure I'd pick Sizemore/Kinsler/Gallardo...

Good luck!

[Fantasy Star]

With the addition of those 2 specific cats. I'd rather have Wright and Berkman who'll both perform better than Sizemore and Kinsler. If it's straight 5x5, then Sizemore and Kinsler get the edge.

[Lakers256P]

More Details...lets see, it is a Keeper League...The side I would be getting is the Sizemore/Kinsler side.... and as it currently stands, my keepers are

Wright
Johan
felix
Berkman
Pujols
Dunn
Papelbon

[Lakers256P]

Bump...Any other opinions?

[Dodgerbluesc]

With Pujols at 1B already I like this even more for you. Remember the 2nd half that Berkman had?

[Lakers256P]

thanks...anyone else? I get the feeling I should do it but im a huge wright fan....

[Lakers256P]

Im getting pressure for a response, can anyone else chime in???

[kidsilk]

I love WRight too but Berkman is expendable and I expect a decline from him this year. Plus you already have Pujols at first. Sizemore is one of my favorite players in baseball and fantasy as I just think his ceiling is so high. Plus Kinsler may be the best second baseman in baseball if you knock Utley for the injury and lack of speed. But, I like this deal for you and would go ahead and do it.