pedroia or hamels keepr league??

[mmullaney]

standard mixed 5x5 10 teams. we can only keep 5 players. players count as the round they were drafted previously. so pedroia counts as a 10th rounder and hamels counts as a 5th rounder. so who woudl be the better keeper? thanks i really need help on this one.

[Tenacious D-Store]

Pedroia, and that's from someone who doesn't value MI's much and fills them mid-late draft.

[jtsandwich]

Pedroia is a 2.5 round draft pick in my opinion and SP Hamels about the 3rd round. Thus the 10th round pedroia is WAY better, not even close, seriously!!!!

[eric31216]

i'm not a huge fan of pedroia but pedroia definitely represents the much better value here

[mmullaney]

good points guys. riddle me this only keeping 5 players which of these 7???
m cabrera 2nd rd
carlos beltran 3rd rd
hamels 5th rd
kemp 8th
bay 9th
pedroia 10th
and lock of teh year... longoria 15th

[etraum]

Longoria, Miggy, Pedroia, Bay and Hamels.

[eric31216]

good points guys. riddle me this only keeping 5 players which of these 7???
m cabrera 2nd rd
carlos beltran 3rd rd
hamels 5th rd
kemp 8th
bay 9th
pedroia 10th
and lock of teh year... longoria 15th

i would go

longoria
cabrera
pedroia
kemp

then bay or hamels. bay would be the better value but if you want to keep a study pitcher hamels would be fine