KEEPER LEAGUE -PEDROIA , PAPI , or CARLOS LEE ?????

[gas house gang]

I'm in a 4 player keeper league . MY other 3 KEEPERS are :

1. Miguel Cabrera 1B 3B
2 Utley 2B
3. Matt Holliday OF

We do 8X8 - avg, runs , SB ,2b ,3b, HR ,RBI ,OBP

Our Positions are:
c ,1b , 2b ,ss ,3b , of , of , of , utility , utility

HERE'S my dilema , I love the #'s PEDROIA put up last year and it will be hard to throw him back in the draft , BUT it will give me two 2B men ...... I thought about trading either PEDROIA OR UTLEY for a top notch player and use the 1 i don't trade at 2B ....... OR should i just keep PEdroia .... or throw him back in and keep BIG PAPI or CARLOS LEE ???? PLEASE HELP !! WHIR !

[mister_jay_peg]

Assuming you make no trades (which throws a wrench in this, because if you trade a keeper, you really should hope to get a keeper back) it comes down to Pedroia or Lee, to me. I don't really trust Ortiz' wrists, and he's getting up there so his bat speed is declining a bit, anyway. (Don't get me wrong, I still like him, but you can pick him back up in the draft.)

So between Pedroia and Lee, I say Lee, with your scoring. Yes, you'll lose a few hits, about 10 steals and maybe 10-ish doubles. But the difference in average is negligible and you get better power numbers.

[Dodgerbluesc]

Assuming you make no trades (which throws a wrench in this, because if you trade a keeper, you really should hope to get a keeper back) it comes down to Pedroia or Lee, to me. I don't really trust Ortiz' wrists, and he's getting up there so his bat speed is declining a bit, anyway. (Don't get me wrong, I still like him, but you can pick him back up in the draft.)

So between Pedroia and Lee, I say Lee, with your scoring. Yes, you'll lose a few hits, about 10 steals and maybe 10-ish doubles. But the difference in average is negligible and you get better power numbers.

[jackthree]

Go with the masher- Lee all the way.

He's a beast, you know what you are going to get with him, and he's going to be healthy all year. Lee no doubt.

Please help!
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=369695

[HOOTIE]

Pedroia easily.
He will win 6 of the 8 catergories.
Better career average, oba. 54 doubles to 27.

[Ernie.Whitt.]

I've yet to be converted to a Pedroia fan... and don't trust Papi. For me, it's Lee.

Please help with mine
viewtopic.php?t=369711

[runxc3200]

I like Lee in this position as well

[kidsilk]

Lee for me too. He is the most consistent of the 3. I dont trust Pedroia to lite it up like he did last year.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=369589

[Tenacious D-Store]

Another vote for Lee.

[gas house gang]

Thanks guys , In you I trust !!!!!!